Lecture 2: Growth Model for Interest Free Economy

Economic growth models traditionally incorporate interest rates as a key determinant of investment, savings, and overall macroeconomic stability. However, in economies that operate under an interest-free framework, such as those following Islamic finance principles or alternative economic systems, the role of interest must be reconsidered. In the same way, the growth model for an interest-free economy is the most important topic to be discussed firsthand before proceeding further.

A Crucial Challenge

A crucial challenge in empirical analysis is how to model growth without directly including interest rates, as simply omitting them may lead to misspecification errors while setting interest to zero in regression may produce statistical inconsistencies. This paper explores how an interest-free economy can be effectively studied within a conventional growth model framework, proposing alternative methodologies such as using proxy variables (e.g., money supply, investment, inflation), structural models (VAR, SEM), and dummy variable techniques to maintain the explanatory power of monetary policy. By adopting the Cobb-Douglas production function and the Solow-Swan growth model, we aim to develop a robust empirical strategy for analyzing economic growth in an environment where interest is not a defining factor.

Conventional Growth Models an Overview

We have the following growth models

1. Cobb-Douglas Growth Model
   • Y_t​=A_t​K_t^α​L_t^1−α
2. ​Solow Growth Model
   • Y_t​=A_t​K_t^α​H_t^β​L_t^1−α−β where H is human capital.
3. ​Endogenous Growth Model
   • Y_t​=AK_t​
   • Here, capital accumulation drives long-run growth without diminishing returns.
4. Harrod-Domar Growth Model (used for investment-driven growth analysis): g=s/k
   • ​ Where:
   • g = Economic growth, rate s = Savings rate, k = Capital-output ratio

Interest-Free Economy

We need to develop some different approaches to studying the interest-free economy. Directly setting or assuming the interest rate zero, will be difficult to study via EViews. In EViews, if you want to estimate a growth model while setting the interest rate (r) equal to zero for the entire time period, you can follow these steps:

Approach 1: Modify the Dataset Before Regression

1. Create a new variable in your dataset where the interest rate is set to zero for all observations: series r_zero = 0
2. Use r_zero instead of the original interest rate variable when running your regression.

Approach 2: Exclude Interest Rate for the Growth Model

If your original regression model is:

Growth = β₀ + β₁Production_Factors + β₂r + ε

Setting r = 0 makes its coefficient irrelevant (β₂*0 = 0), effectively reducing the model to:

Growth = β₀ + β₁*Production_Factors + ε

In this case, simply run the regression without including the interest rate (r) as an explanatory variable.

Impact of Setting Interest Rate (r) to Zero in the Regression Model

If you manually set the interest rate (r) to zero for all time periods and then include it in the regression, the impact on the regression results is as follows:

1. Interest Rate Coefficient Becomes Irrelevant (Zero Effect)

Our regression model typically looks like this: Growth=β₀+β₁⋅Production Factors+β₂⋅r+ε

If r is always zero, then β2⋅0=0 for all observations. This means that r has no effect on Growth, and EViews will estimate β2, but its coefficient will be statistically meaningless because r does not vary.

• Estimated β2​ will likely be zero or have an undefined standard error (multicollinearity issue).
• No change in R-squared (the explanatory power of the model remains the same).
• p-value for β2​ will be very high (showing statistical insignificance).

2. No Impact on Other Coefficients

Since r is always zero, the model effectively reduces to: Growth=β₀+β₁⋅Production Factors+ε

This means the coefficients for Production Factors and other variables will remain unchanged compared to a model where r is omitted.

3. Potential Issues with Model Specification

• Multicollinearity: If r is always zero, its variance is also zero, which can cause singularity issues in the regression estimation.
• Overfitting Warning: Including a variable that has no variation does not add explanatory power, making the model unnecessarily complex.
• EViews Warning Message: Some versions of EViews might show a warning about a “singular matrix” or “near singularity” when trying to estimate the model.

Recommended Approach

Instead of including r = 0, simply omit the interest rate variable and run the regression only with production factors:

ls Growth C Production_Factors

This avoids statistical problems and gives a more meaningful interpretation.

Conclusion

• If you set r=0 but keep it in the model, it has no effect, and its coefficient is statistically meaningless.
• The best approach is to exclude r entirely from the regression.

A Dummy Variable for Zero Interest Rate

If you include a dummy variable that is always equal to zero in your regression to represent an interest-free economy, the dummy variable will have no effect on your model.

Why?

A dummy variable (D) that is always zero means: D=0 for all observations D = 0 for all observations

If you include this in a regression model:

Growth=β₀​+β₁​⋅Production Factors+β₂​⋅D+ε

Since D=0 for all observations, the term β₂⋅0=0, which means that D does not contribute any explanatory power to the model. Essentially, it is as if it was never included.

Correct Approach for an Interest-Free Economy:

If we want to model an interest-free economy, a more appropriate approach is:

1. Set the interest rate (r) to zero manually in the dataset (as we discussed earlier).
2. Remove the interest rate from the regression model instead of using a dummy variable.

Drawback of Omitting Interest Rate in a Growth Model Regression

By completely omitting the interest rate (r) from the regression might suggest it has no role in the economy, which is misleading. However, setting r=0 throughout the dataset and including it in the regression is also problematic because a variable with no variation provides no useful information to the model.

To properly account for the interest rate’s effects in a growth model without directly including it as a variable, consider the following approaches:

1. Use a Proxy Variable for Interest Rate Effects

Instead of using r, which is artificially set to zero, include alternative macroeconomic variables that indirectly capture the effects of interest rates. Some suitable proxies include:

• Money Supply (M2 or M3): Higher interest rates typically reduce money supply, while lower rates increase it.
• Inflation Rate: Interest rates and inflation are closely related due to monetary policy adjustments.
• Investment (Gross Fixed Capital Formation): Interest rates influence investment decisions, so tracking investment can serve as an indirect measure.
• Consumption or Credit Growth: Interest rates impact borrowing and spending, which can be reflected in consumer credit growth.

Modified Regression Model

Instead of: Growth=β₀+β₁⋅Production Factors+β₂⋅r+ε

Use: Growth=β₀+β₁⋅Production Factors+β₂⋅Money Supply+β₃⋅Investment+β₄⋅Inflation+ε

This allows you to capture the indirect effects of interest rates without explicitly including r = 0 in the regression.

2. Use a Structural Model Instead of a Direct Regression

Instead of a single-equation regression, consider a structural model such as:

• Vector Autoregression (VAR): A system of equations modeling relationships between growth, interest rates, inflation, and investment.
• Simultaneous Equations Model (SEM): Models where one equation estimates growth and another estimates interest rate effects.

This approach avoids the issue of setting r=0 while still analyzing its indirect influence.

3. Use a Counterfactual Analysis or Difference-in-Differences (DID)

If we have data for both interest-based and interest-free periods, we can use Difference-in-Differences (DID) to compare economic growth trends. During EViews Analysis of Interest-Free economy, we will prefer this approach.

For example:

1. Identify two time periods or economies (one with interest, one without).
2. Estimate growth separately for both cases.
3. Compare the differences to estimate the effect of moving to an interest-free system.

4. Use a Dummy Variable for the Interest-Free Economy

Instead of setting r=0, create a dummy variable (D) that equals:

• 1 if the economy is operating under an interest-free system.
• 0 if it is operating with interest-based policies.

Then run the regression as: Growth=β₀+β₁⋅Production Factors+β₂⋅D+ε

This allows us to statistically estimate whether being in an interest-free economy affects growth without directly including r = 0.

Conclusion: Best Approach

Since simply setting r=0 causes statistical issues, the best approach depends on your objective:
Use proxy variables (money supply, investment, inflation) to capture interest rate effects.
Apply structural models like VAR or SEM to track the interactions between growth and monetary factors.
Use counterfactual analysis if historical interest-free data is available.
Introduce a dummy variable for interest-free conditions instead of forcing r=0.

This ensures that your model remains statistically valid while still analyzing the effects of an interest-free economy.

*The Impact of Interest-Free Banking on the Economy

---

Incorporating Interest-Free Economic Growth into the Welfare Growth Model (WGM)

The interest-free economic model aligns well with the Welfare Growth Model (WGM) because both frameworks emphasize sustainability, equity, and long-term societal well-being over short-term financial returns. Let’s integrate the principles of an interest-free economy into WGM:

1. Removing Interest from Capital Accumulation (K_t​)

• In a conventional economic model, capital accumulation (K_t) is driven by interest-based lending and investment returns.
• However, in an interest-free economy, investment relies on profit-sharing (Mudarabah), cooperative financing, and state-driven capital allocation.
• In the WGM context, the equation for economic output: Y_t=A_tK_t^0.4H_t^0.6Ω_t can be modified to remove interest-based capital accumulation and instead rely on welfare-backed investments.
• This means welfare spending (W_t​) is not just consumption but also a source of productive reinvestment, enhancing human capital (H_t) and infrastructure.

2. Welfare-Driven Growth Without Interest-Based Debt

• Government Spending: Instead of relying on debt financing with interest, public welfare projects (education, healthcare, housing) can be funded through Islamic finance instruments like Sukuk (Sharia-compliant bonds) and Zakat (wealth redistribution).
• Entrepreneurship & SME Growth: Instead of interest-based loans, financing for businesses can be structured through profit-and-loss sharing mechanisms like Musharakah (equity participation).
• Socially Responsible Investment: Investments in human capital (H_t​) and social welfare programs align with the principles of an interest-free economy, ensuring sustainable development.

3. The Role of Welfare in Capital Allocation

• The function of welfare spending (W_t) expands beyond traditional consumption. In an interest-free economy, welfare resources are invested in productive sectors rather than being allocated through financial institutions charging interest.
• This leads to self-reinforcing economic cycles, where welfare investment enhances productivity, which in turn increases economic growth.

4. Welfare-Weighted Growth Rate with Interest-Free Adjustments

• The Welfare-Adjusted Growth Rate (WAGR) equation: W AGR=(1+g_Y)⋅Ω_t​ can be expanded to include an interest-free financial mechanism where growth comes from real asset-backed investments rather than debt-based expansion.
• By incorporating Zakat-based redistribution, sovereign Sukuk for infrastructure, and profit-sharing business models, the WAGR remains sustainable, inclusive, and ethically aligned with welfare-driven principles.

Conclusion: A Unified Interest-Free Welfare Growth Model

By merging the Welfare Growth Model (WGM) with an interest-free economic framework, we create a self-sustaining economic system where:
Welfare spending enhances productivity (human capital, education, and health).
Capital accumulation is based on real economic assets, not speculative interest-based lending.
Social and economic justice is maintained through redistributive mechanisms (Zakat, Takaful, etc.).
Growth is inclusive, ethical, and long-term sustainable, avoiding financial crises driven by interest-based debt accumulation.

---

Restoring Welfare in an Interest-Free Economy

An interest-free economy requires alternative financial mechanisms to ensure equitable growth, social well-being, and sustainable development. The following key strategies help restore welfare in such an economic system:

1. Profit-Sharing and Risk-Sharing Mechanisms

• Mudarabah (profit-sharing) and Musharakah (joint ventures) replace interest-based lending.
• Encourages equitable wealth distribution and reduces financial exploitation by aligning risks and rewards.

2. Interest-Free Microfinance Institutions

• Organizations like the Akhuwat Foundation (Pakistan) provide Qarz-e-Hasna (interest-free loans) to support entrepreneurship and alleviate poverty.
• Utilizing community structures (e.g., religious places) helps minimize operational costs and promote volunteerism.

3. Redistributive Mechanisms

• Zakat (wealth tax) ensures wealth redistribution from the rich to the poor, reducing inequality.
• Waqf (charitable endowments) funds public goods like education, healthcare, and social infrastructure.

4. Asset-Backed Financing

• Transactions are linked to real assets, ensuring stability and preventing speculative bubbles.
• Ijara (leasing) and Murabaha (cost-plus financing) promote responsible lending and borrowing.
• Sukuk (Islamic bonds) provide a stable alternative to conventional bonds.

5. Encouraging Entrepreneurship and SMEs

• Interest-free economies encourage risk-sharing investments, benefiting small businesses and startups.
• Government-backed equity funds can support innovation and job creation.

6. Stable Monetary Policy Without Interest

• Central banks regulate the money supply using monetary tools like reserve ratios instead of interest rates.
• Inflation is controlled using commodity-backed or digital currency models, ensuring price stability.

7. Ethical and Sustainable Investment

• Speculation (Gharar) and unethical trade (Haram industries) are prohibited, ensuring a sustainable financial system.
• Socially Responsible Investing (SRI) promotes ethical financial practices and long-term welfare.

8. Regulatory Support and Policy Frameworks

• Governments can facilitate interest-free financial systems through supportive legislation and tax incentives.
• Robust regulatory oversight ensures transparency, stability, and protection for all stakeholders.

By adopting these approaches, an interest-free economy can effectively restore welfare, economic stability, and social equity, leading to sustainable development and inclusive prosperity.

---

Interest-Free Economy through the Lens of Behavioral Economics

Behavioral economics challenges the traditional assumption that individuals always act rationally to maximize utility. Instead, human behavior is influenced by psychological biases, social preferences, and cognitive limitations. When analyzing an interest-free economy through the lens of behavioral economics, we can identify how economic agents—individuals, businesses, and policymakers—respond to incentives, risk, and financial mechanisms in the absence of interest-based systems.

1. Risk Perception and Decision-Making in an Interest-Free Economy

• Loss Aversion and Risk-Sharing
  • People tend to fear losses more than they value equivalent gains (prospect theory).
  • Interest-based economies create fixed debt obligations, which increase default risk and financial distress.
  • Risk-sharing contracts (e.g., Mudarabah, Musharakah) align investor and entrepreneur interests, reducing financial anxiety and fostering collective responsibility.
• Framing Effect on Investments
  • Behavioral research suggests that people respond differently to financial risks depending on how choices are presented.
  • Equity-based financing (profit-sharing) is perceived more favorably in an ethical, trust-based framework compared to debt-driven obligations.
  • A well-structured narrative around risk-sharing can enhance participation in interest-free financial systems.

2. Social Preferences and Cooperative Behavior

• Altruism, Reciprocity, and Trust
  • Behavioral studies highlight that people value fairness and ethical finance.
  • Zakat (mandatory wealth redistribution) and Waqf (charitable endowments) leverage social cooperation, fostering economic inclusivity.
  • Interest-free systems reduce wealth concentration and encourage collective welfare, reinforcing reciprocity in economic transactions.
• Peer Influence and Norms in Financial Behavior
  • Social norms shape spending, saving, and investment decisions.
  • Microfinance models (Qarz-e-Hasna) have successfully used peer group lending to minimize defaults by leveraging community trust.
  • People mimic successful financial behaviors, making ethical banking and investment more socially sustainable in an interest-free economy.

3. Incentives and Productivity in an Interest-Free Growth Model

• Intrinsic vs. Extrinsic Motivation in Economic Transactions
  • Behavioral economics suggests that monetary rewards (extrinsic) can sometimes reduce intrinsic motivation to work hard.
  • An interest-driven system promotes loan-based incentives, which may lead to over-leveraging and financial bubbles.
  • Profit-sharing mechanisms ensure that entrepreneurs are intrinsically motivated to perform well since their success is directly tied to investor returns.
• Long-Term Perspective on Investment Behavior
  • Interest-free economies emphasize long-term investments rather than short-term speculative gains.
  • Behavioral insights suggest that present bias (preference for immediate rewards) often leads to debt accumulation in interest-based models.
  • Alternative financing like Sukuk (Islamic bonds) encourages patient capital, fostering sustainable economic growth.

4. Psychological Impact on Financial Stability and Welfare

• Reduced Anxiety and Debt Stress
  • Interest-bearing loans increase financial insecurity, leading to stress and lower productivity.
  • Behavioral economics supports financial models that minimize uncertainty, making risk-sharing structures preferable for mental well-being and economic stability.
• Behavioral Nudges for Ethical Economic Participation
  • Policymakers can nudge individuals toward interest-free finance by promoting default savings plans, ethical investment options, and socially responsible spending habits.
  • Government-backed Shariah-compliant incentives can strengthen consumer trust and participation in an interest-free economy.

Conclusion: A Behavioral Path to Sustainable Growth

By applying behavioral economics to an interest-free economic model, we can enhance financial stability, encourage ethical investments, and improve social welfare. Risk-sharing, fairness, and long-term cooperation become the driving forces of sustainable growth, reducing the vulnerabilities of debt-based financial systems.

---

Research Suggestions

Below are research topics and methodologies that explore economic growth without interest rates, focusing on alternative models, welfare restoration, and behavioral economics.

1. Theoretical and Empirical Analysis of Interest-Free Economic Growth

Research Topic:

• “Evaluating the Impact of an Interest-Free Economy on Economic Growth: A Comparative Study”

Key Questions:

• How does the absence of interest affect GDP growth, investment, and consumption?
• What alternative monetary tools (e.g., reserve ratios, inflation targeting) can replace interest rate policies?

Methodology:

• Apply structural econometric models (VAR, SEM) to compare interest-free economies (e.g., Islamic finance countries) with interest-based economies.
• Use panel data regression to analyze growth trends over time.

2. Alternative Growth Models for Interest-Free Economies

Research Topic:

• “Revisiting the Cobb-Douglas Production Function for Interest-Free Economic Systems”

Key Questions:

• How can we modify the Cobb-Douglas production function to account for profit-sharing (Mudarabah, Musharakah) instead of interest-based capital accumulation?
• Can an interest-free system sustain long-term total factor productivity (TFP) growth?

Methodology:

• Construct an augmented Cobb-Douglas model that replaces capital-interest relationships with equity-based financing.
• Use time-series econometrics to estimate model parameters in interest-free economies.

3. The Role of Proxy Variables in Interest-Free Growth Models

Research Topic:

• “Using Proxy Variables to Measure the Impact of Monetary Policy in an Interest-Free Economy”

Key Questions:

• What are the best proxy variables for replacing interest rates in growth models? (e.g., money supply, investment rate, inflation)
• How effective is Sukuk (Islamic bonds) compared to traditional debt instruments in financing development?

Methodology:

• Use factor analysis to determine the best proxy indicators.
• Apply the Generalized Method of Moments (GMM) to assess the relationship between proxy variables and economic growth.

4. Welfare and Income Distribution in an Interest-Free Economy

Research Topic:

• “The Impact of Interest-Free Economic Policies on Wealth Distribution and Poverty Reduction”

Key Questions:

• How do Zakat, Waqf, and microfinance contribute to income equality?
• Can profit-sharing replace traditional lending in reducing financial exclusion?

Methodology:

• Conduct comparative case studies on economies with active Zakat and Waqf systems.
• Use Gini coefficient analysis to measure the impact on income inequality.

5. Behavioral Economics and Interest-Free Financial Systems

Research Topic:

• “Behavioral Insights into Financial Decision-Making in an Interest-Free Economy”

Key Questions:

• How do risk-sharing mechanisms (Musharakah, Mudarabah) influence investment decisions?
• What behavioral nudges can policymakers use to promote ethical investing and responsible borrowing?

Methodology:

• Conduct experimental studies on financial decision-making in an interest-free framework.
• Use survey-based behavioral analysis to study perceptions of risk-sharing vs. fixed-income lending.

6. Policy Frameworks for Transitioning to an Interest-Free Economy

Research Topic:

• “Monetary Policy in an Interest-Free Economy: Challenges and Policy Recommendations”

Key Questions:

• How can central banks operate effectively without interest rates?
• What policy tools can replace conventional interest rate adjustments for economic stability?

Methodology:

• Develop a macroeconomic simulation model for interest-free monetary policy.
• Conduct historical policy analysis on interest-free financial reforms (e.g., Malaysia, Iran).

---

Critical Thinking

• What are the key economic principles that differentiate an interest-free economy from conventional interest-based systems?
• How does the absence of interest impact capital accumulation, savings, and investment behavior in an economy?
• What historical examples exist of successful interest-free financial systems, and what lessons can be learned from them?
• What are the main challenges of measuring economic growth in an interest-free system?
• How can macroeconomic indicators (e.g., GDP, inflation, investment rates) be adjusted to reflect growth in an interest-free economy?
• What alternative methodologies can policymakers use to stabilize economic cycles without relying on interest rates?
• How does the absence of interest rates influence entrepreneurship, innovation, and business expansion?

• How can proxy variables (e.g., money supply, investment, inflation) replace interest rates in economic growth models?
• What are the advantages and limitations of using structural models (VAR, SEM) to analyze interest-free economies?
• How can the Cobb-Douglas production function be modified to better represent an interest-free economic framework?
• How do Sukuk (Islamic bonds) and equity-based financing impact capital allocation in an economy without interest?
• How does an interest-free economic system affect income distribution, poverty alleviation, and wealth inequality?
• What role do Zakat (wealth tax), Waqf (charitable endowments), and social safety nets play in restoring welfare?
• Can an interest-free economy effectively respond to economic crises (e.g., recessions, financial instability)?
• How do government policy interventions (e.g., taxation, subsidies) differ in an interest-free financial system?
• What challenges might a country face in transitioning from an interest-based to an interest-free economy?

• How do human psychological biases (e.g., risk aversion, loss aversion) influence financial decision-making in an interest-free system?
• What behavioral incentives can be used to promote ethical investing and responsible borrowing in an interest-free economy?
• How does the elimination of debt-based financing impact consumer spending habits and business financing decisions?
• In what ways do trust and social norms play a greater role in financial transactions in an interest-free economy?
• How can behavioral nudges (e.g., default savings options, and ethical investment choices) encourage participation in interest-free financial systems?

---